Why Two Businesses With the Same Sales Can Pay Very Different Processing Fees
It’s a question many business owners ask after comparing notes with peers: “We process about the same amount in sales—so why am I paying more in processing fees?”
The answer is that merchant services pricing isn’t one-size-fits-all. Two businesses with nearly identical sales volume can end up paying very different amounts based on how their payments are set up, how transactions are processed, and what fees are built into their accounts. Here’s why.
1. Pricing Structures Matter More Than You Think
Not all merchant accounts are priced the same way. Some use flat-rate pricing, while others use tiered or interchange-plus models. On the surface, rates can look similar—but the way fees are applied behind the scenes can make a big difference in total cost.
A business with a transparent pricing structure may pay less overall than one with a slightly lower advertised rate that includes hidden or padded fees.
2. How Payments Are Accepted Impacts Cost
The way customers pay matters. Card-present transactions (where a card is tapped, dipped, or swiped) generally cost less than keyed-in or online transactions. If two businesses have the same sales volume but one keys in more transactions, their fees are likely higher.
Security measures like EMV chip and contactless payments can also help reduce costs and risk.
3. Extra Fees Add Up Quickly
Processing fees aren’t just about rates. Monthly charges, statement fees, batch fees, PCI fees, equipment costs, and other line-item charges can quietly increase your total expense.
One business may have fewer add-on fees, while another pays several small charges that add up over time—even if their sales are the same.
4. Business Type & Risk Profile Play a Role
Certain industries are considered higher risk by processors, which can affect pricing. Even within the same industry, differences in transaction size, refund frequency, or chargebacks can influence costs.
Two businesses may look similar on paper, but their processing history can lead to different pricing outcomes.
5. How Often Accounts Are Reviewed (or Not)
Many businesses set up merchant services once and never revisit them. Over time, pricing changes, businesses grow, and better options become available. Without regular reviews, businesses often end up paying more than necessary.
A periodic review can uncover outdated pricing models or fees that no longer make sense.
The Takeaway
- Same sales doesn’t mean same fees. The details behind your merchant account—pricing structure, transaction methods, and added fees—can dramatically impact what you pay each month.
- That’s why a simple review of your current merchant services can be eye-opening.
- Understanding how your account is set up puts you in a better position to control costs, improve transactions, and make sure your payment processing is truly working for your business.






